User blog comment:Sebastian.0315/Best Desperate Mistery/@comment-1586735-20110208192616

I think Mary Alice's mystery was the best. Betty and Orson's mystery was also very good. But, yeah, Season 1's mystery was the strongest.

The weakest was Dave Williams' mystery - if you can even call it a mystery. It ruins Season 5 for me. If Season 5 had a stronger mystery, it would've been one of my favourites..