User blog comment:Bree Weston Lover/What if Edie Wasn't Killed but only suffered an acciendent/@comment-5122449-20120730193350/@comment-4689777-20120730193813

except alot of people. edie taking katherine's s6 story wouldn't work cos she would not have just had her heart broken by Mike and wouldn't go crazy for him, if she had the lesbian storyline she would leave with robin to paris and therefore not be around for s7 and wouldn't do the renee story, but even if she did do the renee story it is unbelievable that edie slept with tom before college and she wouldn't start dating ben cos she'd now be a lesbian and be with robin, and she'd have her wedding to ben and return from paris having brokewn up with robin in the same episode... I think that THAT story is a bit messed up if u asked me where no one is actually happy...